TEAMWORK

Shelter Staff

LEADERSHIP

Thomasina & Amelia

At Tails of Hope, we run Rutland County’s Humane Society like a family. Under the leadership of Thomasina and Amelia, collaboration is at the heart of everything we do. Many of our team members are cross-trained across departments, which means everyone understands how the shelter works as a whole and can step in wherever they’re needed. This structure allows each person to truly own their role while working seamlessly alongside their colleagues. When we work together, the animals in our care are always the ones who benefit most.

Thomasina Magoon

Executive Director

executivedirector@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 211

Thomasina came to Rutland County Humane Society as Development Director in the summer of 2025, and within just a few months, an opportunity arose to step into the role of Executive Director. Having quickly found her footing alongside Shelter Director Amelia Gardner, she recognized immediately that the two of them would make an exceptional team — and that has proven to be true.

While Thomasina arrived without a background in animal welfare, she brought with her a rich and varied career that has always kept her hungry to learn and grow. She started young, spending a decade in the restaurant industry before moving into publishing, then into roles spanning residential and commercial construction and statewide nonprofit work. Most recently, she spent seven years in corporate America, where she gained valuable experience in systems, processes, and organizational strategy. But when it was time to return to the local level — to work that feels less like a job and more like a way of life — Tails of Hope was a perfect fit.

Thomasina has deep roots in Rutland County. She has served on the school board, the selectboard, and in numerous volunteer roles throughout her community, giving her a firsthand understanding of what makes a place truly thrive. She brings that same sense of purpose and investment to her work at Tails of Hope every day, channeling her creativity and energy into helping the animals and families of Rutland County.

She is passionate about the organization’s next chapter — expanding programming and community outreach while continuing to provide a safe, fear-free temporary home for animals as they wait for their forever families.

When she’s not at the shelter, Thomasina can be found in the woods around her home in Goshen, hiking, gardening, and spending time with family. She is also a 30-year professional photographer — a skill that has served her well in connecting with people of all kinds, even in the most wonderfully chaotic moments.

Amelia Gardner

Shelter Director

shelterdirector@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 208

I joined the RCHS family in 2018 and quickly discovered that animal welfare was more than just a career path for me. Over the years I’ve had the privilege of serving in several roles, from fundraising to shelter management, each one deepening my appreciation for the dedicated people and resilient animals that make this work so meaningful.

Animals have been woven into my life from the very start. I grew up learning from a family rooted in veterinary and animal science, and went on to study the latter in college. That love of animals still thrives in my household today, which includes my husband, two daughters, our dogs, and a horse.

After growing my family and returning to the shelter in a new chapter of life, I realized how much I had missed being close to the daily rhythm of animal care. Stepping into the role of Shelter Director has been a true honor, and I’m so grateful to work alongside a team that shares the same commitment to compassion and quality care. Whether I’m working with the RCHS team, out on the trails, or spending time with my own animals, this field continues to inspire me to grow. For me, shelter work is a way of life; one I’m proud to be a part of every day.

 

ADOPTION CENTER

Casey, Tori and Miranda

Finding the right match between a pet and a family is both an art and a calling. Our Adoption Center team is dedicated to counseling-based adoptions, taking the time to sit with each visitor, learn about their lifestyle, their home, and the people and pets already in it. Sometimes someone comes in with one animal in mind and leaves with a completely different, and perfect, match. Beyond adoptions, our team manages community clinics, connects adopters with training and behavioral resources, and follows up at three days, three weeks, and three months to make sure every animal’s transition to their forever home is a success.

Casey Tolstoi

Adoption Programs Coordinator

adoptionprograms@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 202

“If I were an animal, I’d definitely be a goat, specifically one of those fainting goats. I fully relate to their dramatic energy and love for random, impromptu naps whenever possible.”

I may be new to the animal welfare field professionally, but caring for others has always been at the center of who I am. For the past 15+ years, I worked in education and child development, working closely with children and families in a variety of settings. While my previous experience was not directly with animals, I strongly believe the skills translate naturally into the work we do at the humane society every day.

Throughout my career, I’ve spent years building relationships, communicating effectively, earning trust, and learning how to support both children and their families through patience, compassion, and understanding. Those same qualities are incredibly important in animal welfare; whether it’s helping animals feel safe, supporting adopters, or connecting with the community.

Ever since I can remember, my childhood dream was to become a veterinarian. While life ultimately took me down a different path, somehow it still led me right where I was meant to be. Being able to combine my passion for helping others with my lifelong love for animals has made working at the humane society incredibly meaningful to me. One of my favorite childhood animals was my Great Dane, Sophie. She was truly the gentlest giant and somehow fully tolerated all of my childhood “spa day” ideas. We used to have pedicure and dress-up days together, and she went along with every second of it like the queen she was. I specifically remember this black and purple witch Halloween costume that fit her perfectly. Pair that with neon green nail polish, and she looked absolutely fabulous.

Mom life has absolutely consumed me these past two years, so as far as hobbies go, I honestly haven’t had much time to think about myself. Most of my time and energy is spent being “mom,” and I wouldn’t trade that for anything. But when I do happen to get a spare moment, I love a quiet cup of coffee, listening to music, or baking something new.

Tori Fischer

Adoptions & Communications Coordinator

communications@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 202

“If I were an animal, I’d be a Golden Retriever. I am loyal, a (recovering) people-pleaser, and I absolutely love being told I am doing a good job!”

I grew up with acreage and lots of animals. I had horses, Kapu and Sonny, a Great Dane, Titan, Dachshunds, Gretal and Toby, a Chinese Crested, Andy, a cockatiel Pikachu, African Grey parrot, Peewee, and raised 20 chickens. My favorite memories are exploring, galloping through fields, and swimming in rivers.

I have been a foster volunteer at The Rutland County Humane Society since October 2024. Growing up, I worked in barns, bartering labor for riding lessons. Animals taught me resilience, falling off my pony taught me to always get back up and keep trying, even when scared.

I love teamwork and am excited to work with passionate people who share the goal of getting animals into happy, healthy homes. Working alongside four-legged creatures is the ultimate bonus! I’m also interested in furthering my experience with community engagement and to meeting more people! 

Biking, skiing—specifically telemark skiing (free the heel), snowboarding, hanging with loved ones and family, camping, swimming, and cuddling with my two dogs. Pop Culture & Comforts: Avatar: The Last Airbender, reality TV, and listening to pop or alternative pop. My absolute go-to karaoke song is Toxicity by System of a Down!

ANIMAL INTAKE, HEALTH & WELLBEING

Jennifer, Sharlot & Haley

Intake is often one of the most emotionally sensitive moments in both an animal’s journey and in a family’s. Jennifer leads our intake process with compassion and patience, understanding that surrendering a pet or bringing in an animal in need requires a counseling-based, empathetic approach. From there, Sharlot takes the reins on animal health, conducting thorough wellness checks upon arrival and maintaining preventative care protocols for every animal in our shelter, including those in foster homes. Haley keeps a close eye on where every animal is housed within the shelter, works closely with our Volunteer Coordinator to ensure adequate coverage, and helps identify foster placements, often on very short notice. Together, their combined efforts reflect the power of a dedicated team.

Jennifer Lalli

Animal Intake & Community Outreach Coordinator

animalintake@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 209

“If I were an animal I’d want to be a spoiled house cat just like my own; Naps whenever you want, food delivered on demand, and someone else worrying about the bills – honestly, who wouldn’t sign up for that?”

I am Jennifer Summer Lalli and I love my job at RCHS! I am able to use my lifelong skills with animals and people towards a meaningful goal. Previous to my work at RCHS, I rescued and fostered on my own. Those animals were of all walks of life. Rodents, reptiles, birds, fish, crabs, rabbits, horses, sheep, and of course, cats and dogs! They have taught me many lessons and I love them all. Currently I live with my cat Tiffany. She is leash trained and knows many circus tricks! My animal family also includes my tarantula Wednesday and my fish, Erik. They are all rescues. We are surrounded by fifty or so houseplants. When I am not at work I enjoy fly-fishing, gardening, snowboarding and kayaking. I adore being outside with nature. A simple walk makes me happy. When I am inside, I like to knit, read, draw, and watch movies.

One of my favorite aspects of my involvement with RCHS is getting to know the animals in our care. They are all special in their own, unique way. My actual favorite part is when a pet find its home. Whether it was a stray, surrendered or simply lost. We all celebrate! We are a team and I am so proud to be a part of it.

Sharlot Hall

Animal Health & Wellness Coordinator

animalhealth@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 205

“If I had to choose and animal to be, I would be a dog, they give off such good energy and are able to make most people smile.”

I am a dog person! I didn’t have many pets as a child but over the years I have had several and by far the best dog I have ever had was my Lola (pug). Lola enjoyed lazy afternoons on the couch, and four-wheeler rides. She was so much fun and just the snuggliest. She was my little Rug Slug.

I have always wanted to work with animals and have worked at several shelters throughout my life, including RCHS many years ago. I decided well why not do what I love. My family encouraged me to apply and so I did. I feel like I can make a difference in the lives of the animals and families who adopt. My hobbies include camping with my family, traveling and anything water related.

 

Haley Mallette

Animal Wellbeing & Care Manager

animalhealth@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 204

“If I was an animal I would be a hummingbird. I too am small and constantly on the move!”

I am a resident of Proctor and joined RCHS in 2022, looking for a meaningful and rewarding career working with animals, something that quickly became my passion. With a big heart and a deep love for animal welfare, I am dedicated to being the voice for those who don’t have one, advocating for the care, comfort, and well-being of every animal that comes through our shelter.

As Animal Care Manager, I take pride in creating a supportive, compassionate environment not only for the animals, but for my team as well. I am Fear Free certified and certified in Dog Enrichment. I am a strong believer in leading with kindness and work closely with my staff to ensure every animal receives the best care possible.

Outside of work, I enjoy spending time with my husband, our two daughters and our border collie, Eleanor. In the warmer months, I can often be found tending to my flower gardens.

VOLUNTEER & FOSTER PROGRAMS

Mary

Our volunteer and foster programs have been completely transformed over the past several months, and the credit belongs to one person: Mary St. Peter. Since taking on this role, Mary has built a thriving, organized program from the ground up; maintaining a robust volunteer database, managing weekly scheduling, and tracking exactly what each volunteer is able to do, from dog walking to cleaning to transport assistance. Our foster network has grown into a reliable and responsive community of caregivers we can call on in a pinch. Mary works closely with leadership and our animal care team on collaborative initiatives every single day.

Mary St. Peter

Volunteer Coordinator

volunteer@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 206

“If I were an animal, I would be a dog. Dogs hold a special place in my heart, and I believe every dog encountered leaves behind a lasting impression a paw print on the soul that never truly fades”

Mary brings her strong business background with a lifelong love of animals, especially dogs, to her role at RCHS. She holds a Master of Business Administration and a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration, bringing strategic insight, organizational skill, and a technical mindset to the shelter’s volunteer program.

Mary joined RCHS as a volunteer after her retirement in early 2025, assisting with dog walking and various shelter tasks. Inspired to help further, she offered her business and administrative experience to support the shelter behind the scenes. Mary became the Volunteer Coordinator in November, 2025. In her current role, she streamlines volunteer scheduling, improves communication, and ensures the volunteer procedures are consistently followed so that the program runs efficiently with every volunteer feeling supported and valued.

Outside of her work at RCHS, Mary enjoys an active lifestyle. She rides her bicycle year-round, plays tennis, hikes with Brooklyn and her fiancé, Peter, teaches fitness, and loves skiing whenever she can. Whether coordinating volunteers at the shelter or exploring the outdoors with her family, her dedication to animal welfare and her love for dogs shine through in everything she does.

DEVELOPMENT, MARKETING & COMMUNCATIONS

Jeff, Lauren, Miranda & Tori

Our Development and Marketing team is the voice of Tails of Hope. They connect us with our community, in Rutland County and beyond. They act as a voice for animals in need and drive the support that makes our mission possible. Jeff, Lauren, Miranda, and Tori work together to ensure that every gift is acknowledged, every donor feels valued, and our database is current and well-maintained. From fundraising campaigns and community events to social media and donor communications, this team makes sure we can keep doing the work we love and that the people who make it possible always know how much their generosity means.

Jeff Sinos

Donor Support Coordinator

donorsupport@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 207

“If I were an animal, I would be a sloth because they are never in a hurry”

My favorite part of working at RCHS is watching an animal rehabilitated back to good health. I wasn’t allowed to have a dog or a cat as a child, as both of my parents had allergies. So instead, I would give neighborhood cats milk on his parents porch. Eventually my parents shut that operation down.

That being said, I did have a few childhood pets. I loved tortoises. I got a Russian Tortoise in 7th grade, back when Rutland had multiple pet stores. The first tortoise was named Terminator. Then Terminator 2 came along, and went to college with me.

I ended up getting a baccalaureate of Social Work as well as 3 Himalayan cats, Maya, Cali, and Bugg. Only straight man in Vermont with 3 floofy cats! I started working at the Humane Society after I discovered I preferred working with animals more than people. My hobbies include oil painting, guitar, and collecting baseball cards.

Lauren Escott

Development Coordinator

development@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 203

“If I was an animal, I would be a black cat, because all black cats are witches.”

I was a volunteer here at Rutland County Humane Society for over a year before I became the Development Coordinator. My past experience includes nonprofit development work for Habitat for Humanity, Central Connecticut State University, and Girl Scouts of Connecticut. With my passion for nonprofit work and helping animals, this role was the perfect fit.

My first childhood pet will fur-ever have my heart. I was seven years old when my parents took me to our local humane society to adopt our family’s first puppy. But when we got there, all the puppies had been adopted. I should say all the small puppies. The only one left was a Saint Bernard mix, and at only 6 months old he was the size of a full-grown golden retriever. As soon as he came into the meet and greet room, I knew he was my dog. He was cream and light brown, which I thought looked like coffee. So his name became Cheeno, short for Cappuccino. As an only child, he instantly became my best friend and I will never forget him.

My current pack is quite the mixed bag.  I have a ten-year-old chihuahua mix who is the true representation of a grumpy old man. But get him a new squeaky toy and he will run all over the house like a puppy.  We then rescued Opal, a deaf and partially blind super mutt, from a euthanasia list. I know American Sign Language and she is very smart so we have taught her many signs to communicate with her. Our final adoption to complete the pack was Marnie, our beautiful black cat. She absolutely is a good witch, and her hobbies include bird watching and curling up in bed with us every night.

All my hobbies revolve around my animals. Marnie likes to sit on my books when I am reading. Jasper likes to taste the fruits of my labor in the vegetable garden. And Opal loves to go hiking with us. I am so happy to be working in a job where I can make a real difference in animals’ lives.

Miranda Martin

Marketing Coordinator

marketing@rchsvt.org
(802) 483-6700 Ext 210

“If I were an animal, I’d be a mink! They are curious and always on the move. I appreciate their attitude/vibe”

My love for animals began in childhood. From as early as I can remember, animals have been my happy place. I was always jumping at every opportunity to pet-sit neighborhood dogs and cats or help out in my grandmother’s pet store. Courtesy of my grandmother, we had a dachshund named Sandy growing up, though she went by many names; puppy, twinkie, ect. I also had a beloved cat named Velma, who I had from age 2 to age 20. We would climb trees together outside. I would bring a book and sit up there for hours.

Working at RCHS is something I feel I have been building towards my entire life thus far. Living locally, I would pass Rutland County Humane Society when running errands with my mom, or on my way to extracurricular activities. Every time I would beg for her to stop in, so I could see the animals. For fun, I would watch Petfinder and check the Humane Society’s website, creating PowerPoint presentations of animals for my parents, in the hopes I could convince them to foster/adopt one of the animals.

I eventually went off to college to pursue a Bachelor’s of Science in psychology and was given an amazing opportunity to volunteer for an equine therapy program. I now spend my days teaching my Shepherd Mix, Arlo, various tricks and watering my copious number of plants. Outside of work, I primarily pursue creative pursuits. I have been collecting musical instruments since I was a teenager, hunting down old trumpets and guitars at yard sales. Currently I produce and record music for fun. I am also the proud fur-mom of two cats, who I adopted as a bonded pair; Caster and Pollux (Lux).

ANIMAL WELLBEING & CARE

Del, Darcy & Ava

This team is the heartbeat of our shelter. Every single day, our Animal Caretakers show up and do the work that keeps our animals healthy, comfortable, and loved. They clean kennels and cat suites, do laundry, wash dishes, and making sure every space feels safe and welcoming. The animals they care for are part of their working family, and that love shows in everything they do. Our shelter is the animals’ temporary home and their place of healing. This extraordinary team makes sure it always feels that way until each one finds their forever home.

Darcy Nelson

Animal Wellbeing Caretaker

“If I were an animal, I’d be a beaver because I’m task oriented and I like to get stuff done but I’m also very loyal.”

At six years old, I fed treats to the neighbors’ dog through their fence because they worked all day and I felt bad Duchess was out there all alone. They ended up giving her to me, and so many of my best childhood memories include Duchess. That experience inspired my relationship with RCHS, where I became a volunteer in 2011. I’ve fostered cats, kittens, puppies, and dogs in my home, worked at RCHS community events and fundraisers, and served on the Executive Board of Directors. In my current role in Animal Care, I feel rewarded knowing how important it is to be a part of this caring team. The joy of seeing animals get a second chance at happiness, being loved and cared for, is truly indescribable!

Ava Champine

Animal Wellbeing Caretaker

“If I were an animal I would be a hyena… they’re underrated. They’re also matriarchal and I highly relate to that because I think woman make strong leaders.”

Ava’s passion for animal started early. As a kid, she had a dog named Vixen. She was a miniature pinscher/terrier mix with more nicknames than you’d think one dog could handle, including Vixen Chicken, Chichi, Cheecher, Pep, and Pepper. That love for animals only grew, leading her to take up her first job as an animal wellbeing caretaker here at Tails of Hope! She’s no stranger to animal care. She grew up helping take care of her mom’s four dogs and two cats. Beyond caretaking, she’s passionate about dog sports and hopes to compete in one herself someday; so far, she’s gotten to try dock diving, and she’s hooked.

Ava is currently working toward college with plans to become a vet tech; making this hands-on experience an especially meaningful step in her journey. For her, the best part of working in animal care is knowing she’s making a difference in her community and helping animals along the way.

Outside of work, she’s usually reading, hiking, or catching some sun. She’s a big fan of dog sports, Supernatural, Noah Kahan, and pretty much everything about fall.